Showing posts with label barney frank. Show all posts
Showing posts with label barney frank. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Slapped by the facts



Abandoned farm home - Great Depression
Home ownership is typically the largest financial asset of most American families. Equity (the excess value of your home above its mortgage balance) can be tapped to buy a needed new car, finance renovations, or send your kids to college. In retirement, with the mortgage discharged, the home may be sold to finance a nice retirement in Florida, Texas, or some other low tax (and high sun) haven.

Further, home ownership has proved to foster a sense of community far stronger than that of transient rental populations. Neighborhoods with high individual ownership rates tend to be neater and calmer and just nicer to live in. So it’s no wonder that government has fostered the notion that taxpayers’ pockets should be tapped to increase the general overall home ownership rate. What’s not to like about this?

Therefore in bipartisan fashion (meaning both Democrats and Republicans), we passed the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) in 1977. The CRA was intended to coerce banks to make loans that they would not otherwise make. This is odd in that the language of the CRA also required that banks maintain sound and prudent lending practices. In typical government fashion, the banks were put into a bind that they could not escape. If they declined to make loans to uncreditworthy applicants, they would be punished. But if they made loans to uncreditworthy applicants, they would be punished. What’s a poor banker to do?

Since the punishment for not making loans was far greater, the loans rolled out. In association with other government “affordable housing” initiatives, down payments fell as low as 3.75% and losses were insured by the Federal Housing Authority (FHA). Lenders were incented to lend (protected from losses) and borrowers were incented to borrow, all lubricated by taxpayer largess.

The CRA was amped up in 1995 (Clinton) and again in 2005 (Bush). Politicians of both parties love to give our money away. And what did this largess gain us?

The financial crisis of 2008.

While there has been much argument that the CRA (and related government “affordable housing” programs) had no effect on the economy nor led to the financial crisis, a simple application of common sense might indicate otherwise.
  • Would a down payment of 20% result in a sounder applicant than 3.75%? In other words, on a $200,000 loan, would you be more likely to walk away (default) if you had paid $40,000 down versus $7,500?
  • As a mortgage originator, would you be more or less likely to grant a loan if you knew that the government would cover your losses?
Well, a recent study published by an independent, nonpartisan economic think tank has given us some answers. The National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), based in Cambridge Massachusetts, has studied the impact of the Community Reinvestment Act. In their report, the NBER pulls no punches. “Did the Community Reinvestment Act(CRA) lead to Risky Lending? Yes, it did... We find that adherence to the act led to riskier lending by banks."


Read more here: http://voices.kansascity.com/entries/yes-community-reinvestment-act-encouraged-banks-make-risky-loans/#storylink=cpy

Barney Frank, who famously gambled with our money in 2003, had this to say then: “I want to roll the dice a little bit more in this situation towards subsidized housing." But by 2010, Rep. Frank had come to realize the error of his ways: "…it was a great mistake to push lower-income people into housing they couldn't afford and couldn't really handle once they had it." Even Barney was jarred into reality when slapped by the facts.

This sad tale reinforces the damage that the government can inflict when meddling with free markets. Although the intentions were admirable, the outcome was disastrous. Sometimes it’s best to let common sense, and a deep understanding of human nature, reign.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Risky Business

Chilling. After all we’ve been through (and it’s not over yet), a well-known mortgage originator on a Boston-area talk radio station is shilling such: “Low credit? No credit? No problem! We can get you an FHA loan! No income verification!”

Imagine the black sheep in your family. Nice guy. He’s family, so you love him. But you’d never lend him a buck that you expected repaid – he’s not the responsible type. Everyone knows someone like that. Would you give him a $300,000 mortgage with no income verification? No? Well, Uncle Sam will.

Thank you Barney. The mindset that foreclosure risk should be underwritten by the taxpayers is a staple of liberal, progressive philosophy. It got us where we are, and it’s difficult to believe that we haven’t yet learned our lesson.

Friday, June 5, 2009

A conflict of interests...

All that needs to be said about government involvement in the market was revealed to us by Barney Frank yesterday (6/4/09). GM (the newly formed Government Motors) had determined to reduce costs by rationalizing logistical needs in the face of foreseeable business volumes. To that end, GM decided to consolidate parts warehouses and a GM distribution center in Norton, MA, was slated to be closed.

Enter Rep. Frank (D – MA), a veteran of the auto industry, who issued an-offer-that-could-not-be-refused to GM executives. The executives understandably caved and GM has reconsidered that closing

Now, the relative merits of closing or not closing that warehouse may be argued. But what is not debatable is that GM made the original decision based on an analysis of business conditions, while Barney Frank’s intervention was wholly political, intended to enhance his power and extend his tenure.

That, alone, is reason enough to look askance at government programs that might be better served by the market. Single payer health care springs to mind.