Showing posts with label statistics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label statistics. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 22, 2016

A Healthy, Happy Life in Spite of Media Hype



It is sad how we respond to media-generated hype and hysteria.

The 24 x 7 news void demands to be filled, and by golly, they do indeed fill it. 

Why a police chase ending in a rollover blocking the 405 south of Los Angeles is pertinent, we don’t know. But we are compelled to watch the gripping video. Ask a hard question – is the news you watch mostly useful, or is it mostly entertainment? 

Remember that the networks and cable news outlets are driven by a chase for revenue. The news arms of the majors (ABC, CBS, NBC) and the cable networks – CNN, MSNBC, Fox News – all are competing to keep your eyes glued to their particular screen.  The stories they feature are not primarily designed to make you a better citizen, or to keep you safe, but rather to maximize their advertising revenue. 

Take, for example, the stereotypical “stranger-danger” child kidnapping. As a media maven, one would think that these events have gone through the roof. Children are no longer permitted to walk to school or play alone because of such dangers. A child kidnapping in far-off Atlanta or Houston is emblazoned on our screens, not to help recover the child, but as a ploy to keep you watching the commercials.

To the contrary, a recent Department of Justice bulletin reports that such child kidnappings have not increased. The study found that approximately 105 child kidnappings occurred nationwide in 2011, about the same as in 1997. And more importantly, the number of deaths resulting from such events fell dramatically, from 40 percent to 8 percent. (The authors of the study credit technology – cell phones, GPS, security cameras – for making kids easier to recover). Bottom line – kids are safer now than ever.

This one example gives us some guidance – as a citizen, as a voter, as a parent, our best defense is to be well armed with relevant information. Our government does a great job of gathering and publishing statistics, and it is free for you to access.

For instance, here are the leading causes of death in the United States for 2014 from the Centers for Disease Control (CDC).



A quick glance at the big top four should convince you that diet and exercise and a healthy lifestyle should be your highest priority. 

Next is to take care to avoid accidents (unintentional falls being a significant portion of them).

Not much can be done yet to avoid Alzheimer’s disease although general good health, diet, and exercise are thought to help, along with maintaining strong social interactions.

Numbers seven through nine again speak to health, nutrition, and lifestyle.

Drug overdose and suicide are both very sad causes of death, perhaps interrelated. All we can do there is to support our loved ones and call for increased funding for rehabilitation and mental health programs. 

Finally to the most dangerous form of transportation known to man – our cars. Help is on the horizon with autonomous (self-driving) cars promising to greatly increase safety. In the meantime, you can take care to buckle up and don't drive under the influence (one third of motor vehicle fatalities involve alcohol-impaired drivers).

Not on the list but top of mind recently is homicide. The death rate for all homicides is 5.1 per 100,000 people. (Interestingly, that rate has declined over 50% from a high of 10.4 in 1980). Death by firearm is a fraction of that, 3.5 per 100,000. And unless you live in a drug-infested urban enclave, your odds of meeting this particular fate are exceedingly low.

Here are a few observations that may contribute to the length and quality of your life. First, shut off the cable news – it is not serving your best interests. Read your local newspaper – what is going on around you is far more important. And for goodness sake, put down that cheeseburger and go for a hike once in a while. 

The statistics demand it.


Thursday, September 20, 2012

Lies, damned lies, and the financial meltdown



Luther Burbank, visionary, namesake.
A recent article in the Attleboro Sun Chronicle welcomes three new principals to our local school system (“Class Acts”, 9/3/2012). It is a heartwarming article and we all share in the excitement and promise of these promotions. But then, almost an afterthought, we notice something – the three new principals are all female.

There is a little known statistic that approximately half of our population is male. So when three executive positions are filled in the district, mightn’t we expect that at least one would be male?

Curious, we check the district’s website. Of the ten executive positions (nine principals and the superintendent), two are male and eight female. It looks pretty grim for the local guys.

On its face, just based on the numbers, this is highly discriminatory.

But there are lots of good reasons for the disparity. There are cultural and social forces at work that make the pool of female educators much larger than that of males. Females enter the profession at a much higher rate than males. The federal government (National Center for Education Statistics) reports that as of 2008, 76% of all public school teachers were female. So the fact that 80% of Attleboro’s school executives are female is not far off the mark.

It just goes to show that sometimes prima facie (“on its face”) discrimination can be explained by a deeper understanding of background facts.

Meanwhile, there is a small California savings and loan institution named after Luther Burbank, the famed botanist. Luther Burbank Savings was founded in 1983, committed to serving and retaining its customers rather than profiting public stockholders.

The bank is financially conservative and handily survived the financial meltdown of 2008. It did so by avoiding exotic financial vehicles such as sub-prime mortgages and collateralized mortgage obligations. It held the mortgages it issued for its own portfolio and did not sell them off. The funds released to mortgage borrowers came from the bank’s own depositors to whom it owed a fiduciary duty of care. It was successful because it required borrowers to qualify for the mortgage commitments they were about to undertake.

It would seem that this behavior should be congratulated and emulated. If more banks had behaved like this, there would have been no housing bubble and no financial meltdown.

So to honor Luther Burbank, your Department of Justice sued them for maintaining loan policies that had a “disparate impact” on African-Americans and Hispanics. The government observed that loans were made to the minority community at a statistically lower rate than their population.

The bank, admitting no guilt, settled the suit to avoid ruinously expensive litigation. It has loosened its lending standards and its depositors money is now at much greater risk. This is all due to the government’s “disparate impact” theory which says, regardless of fundamental causes, that if statistical variances exist, they must be discriminatory. No analysis of underlying causes is permitted.

If the problem is that minorities fail to qualify for standard mortgages, then we need to address those core issues. Holding a figurative gun to the head of a small community bank and forcing it to take greater risks runs counter to the lessons learned since 2008. And basing this on superficial statistics seems nonsensical at best.

If similar reasoning were applied to the Attleboro School district’s hiring policies, heads would roll.

Thursday, May 28, 2009

Summer safety -- myth vs. reality

With summer approaching and the end of the school year nigh, we must be vigilant regarding the safety of our children. Parents, rightfully, are concerned for the safety of their children. A popular parenting website offers this featured article: Gun Safety - Do You Ask About Weapons Before a Playdate? Skittish parents are warned that forty percent of homes with kids also have guns and that “eight kids die every day from guns” (emphasis in original).


Humans tend to be very poor processors of risk information, and that tendency is greatly exacerbated by downright bad information. The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) statistics for 2004 (last full year available) states that for children 5-14, a total of 41 were killed by accidental firearm discharges. (Unless you allow your child to play hopscotch on the drug war battlefields, your chief concern should be accidental death by firearm). While 41 deaths are tragic, that is a far cry from the 2,922 deaths asserted in the article (the yearly total of 8 per day).


So what should you, as a caring and responsible parent, be concerned about? While guns are popularly vilified, they are way down on the list. According to CDC statistics, here’s what you should be asking your playdate’s adult family (mom, dad, steps, uncles, aunts, etc.):

  1. Do you have a bad driving record? Any DUI convictions? In 2004, 1,453 children aged 5-14 were killed in transportation-related accidents (overwhelmingly in automobiles). Odds – 64.3%
  2. Do you have a pool, or will you be taking my child to the beach? Over 250 children died by drowning in the same period. Odds – 11.3%
  3. Is your home protected by fire and smoke alarms? How about a sprinkler system? More than 180 kids died from smoke, fire, or flames. Odds – 8.0%
  4. Are all of your household poisons (cleaning solutions, etc.) safely locked up? Nearly 60 kids died from poisoning in 2004. Odds – 2.6%
  5. Finally we get to the firearms question – with 41 accidental deaths. Odds – 1.8%











While it may be fashionable and politically correct to vilify firearms, a truly responsible parent will pay attention to the real probabilities. Maybe it’s time for a Brady Campaign to Prevent Traffic Violence. It would be much more effective in actually savings kids’ lives.