Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 27, 2016

Wealth in the modern world



Maasai herder with cattle

With the primary election season upon us, there has been a lot of attention focused on income and wealth. Particularly that of the 1%.

In a widely reported account, Oxfam released a study last week purporting that just 62 billionaires possessed as much wealth as half of the world’s population. Without delving into the politics of equality, taxation, and redistribution, let’s simply look at why that might be.

The first question one might ask is how is wealth measured? In our Western sense, wealth is measured in dollars: the equity in our homes and other possessions, the value of our 401Ks and other bank accounts. These assets are currency-denominated. But to a Maasai nomad, wealth is measured by the number of cattle he owns. The value of those bovines is not likely to show up in Oxfam’s report.

But that is to quibble. It is undeniably clear that Bill Gates holds more assets than all of the Maasai tribes put together, regardless of how those assets are measured.

Another minor confusion to clear up is the distinction between income and wealth. Income is the flow of net additional assets accruing to an individual, typically from labor (wages) or return on capital (investments). For the Maasai, income is measured in milk, not in steaks.

Oxfam does not confuse these, but politicians and the media have a free-for-all, mixing income and wealth in a confusing mélange of “who owns what” and “who earns what.” The answers can be greatly different, with wildly differing effects on public policy. It is wise to learn the difference. 

But let’s refocus on wealth, and who holds it, and why.

Between the Civil War years and the mid-twentieth century, we saw enormous growth in this country. This was due largely to technological advances. In these eighty years, we saw the coming of the transcontinental railroad, coast-to-coast telegraphy and telephony, massive steelworks, sprawling oilfields, and the capital accumulation (banks) to finance all of it.

The names are famous. Cornelius Vanderbilt (railroads and shipping), John D. Rockefeller (petroleum), Andrew Carnegie (steel making), Henry Ford (automobiles), and J.P. Morgan (banking). These, along with many others, built twentieth century America. And for their pains, for their risk taking, they became enormously wealthy. (Completely unknown are the stories of thousands of other entrepreneurs who tried and failed. Only the successful made it into our consciousness).

Did these vaunted capitalists deserve their wealth? One can only compare the lives of a woman in 1870 to one in 1940. The latter woman could call a relative on a far coast, just to chat. She could travel there in mere days, not months. She was able to listen to entertaining radio programs and wash her clothes in a new-fangled wringer/washer. She could drive to the grocery store and buy fresh bananas recently imported from Nicaragua. And place her homogenized milk in an electric refrigerator, keeping it fresh for days. These were the most wrenching changes in the history of mankind, in only one lifetime.

Many millions experienced these benefits. Was it immoral for the Vanderbilts and Rockefellers, Carnegies and Fords, to have accumulated great wealth as a result? What if the opposite were attained – no wealth, no such advances?

In the current debate, Oxfam lists sixty two billionaires who hold half of the world’s wealth. Let’s ask, what have they done to deserve it? With limited space, here are a few:

A couple of Waltons – $161 billion – Walmart
Bill Gates – $79.2 billion – Microsoft (Windows et al)
Warren Buffett - $72.7 billion – Berkshire Hathaway, Geico (the little lizard)
Larry Page and Sergey Brin –  $58.9 billion – Google
Jeff Bezos – $34.8 billion – Amazon
Mark Zuckerberg, $33.4 billion – Facebook

Let’s imagine stripping these people of their wealth and erasing their companies. No more Walmart “everyday low prices.” No more Microsoft Windows (OK, that’s a mixed blessing). Goodbye little lizard and the millions of home and auto insurance policies he represents. No more Google – look it up yourself at the library. So long Amazon, can’t order those terrific shoes for delivery on Friday. And the cruelest cut of all – no more silly cat videos on Facebook to share with your many “friends.”

In the end, the populists have possibly won the debate. While the capitalists of the Golden Era instituted the greatest advances in human history, thoroughly earning their wealth, the most recent ones have simply provided us with convenience and entertainment.

In the end, we need to determine how much that is worth.

Friday, November 29, 2013

Obamacare - Mind-numbing Complexity



"Professor Butts and the Self-Operating Napkin"
The implementation of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act is causing some considerable perplexity and dissension among the citizenry. But its goal is crystal clear.  According to Kathleen Sibelius, Obamacare’s primary objective is to “make coverage more secure for those who have insurance, and extend affordable coverage to the uninsured.”

This presumes that expanded insurance coverage will improve health, and well it might. But this is not a given – there are many other factors affecting the nation’s health. (Hint – obesity, alcohol, tobacco).

A secondary goal of Obamacare is to “bend the cost curve”, that is, to make health care (and hence insurance premiums) cost less than it otherwise would have. Again, this is within the realm of the possible, perhaps over a long time frame. But early experience shows 2014 insurance premiums increasing at an alarming rate, often double the cost of 2013.

A key feature of Obamacare is its complexity: a multitude of tightly interdependent moving parts. The inauspicious roll out of Healthcare.gov (termed a "debacle" by the administration) is only a symptom of the law's impenetrable convolution. 

One might make reference to Rube Goldberg, whose contraptions were fantastically complex. But in the end, they could actually be made to work. The administration is fervently hoping for such good fortune.

As well meaning as it is, Obamacare has two fundamental shortcomings:
  1. Mind-numbing complexity
  1. Valiant but misdirected goals
To the first point, Obamacare features a flurry of economic features intended to fund the program. These include requiring all policies to provide a broad range of “essential” services regardless of whether the policyholder wants or needs those services. For instance, young single men do not require maternity coverage but will be forced to pay for it. Older folks do not need pediatric care but are obligated to purchase it. This is not “essential” coverage at all but, rather, hidden taxes.

But Obamacare has plenty of obvious taxes, too. From a sympathetic website (www.obamacarefacts.com), here is a partial list of Obamacare taxes:
  • 2.3% Tax on Medical Device Manufacturers
  • 10% Tax on Indoor Tanning Services
  • Blue Cross/Blue Shield Tax Hike
  • Excise Tax on Charitable Hospitals which fail to comply with the requirements of Obamacare
  • Tax on Brand Name Drugs
  • Tax on Health Insurers
  • Elimination of tax deduction for Rx drug coverage with Medicare Part D
  • Employer Mandate $2000 to $3000 per employee
  • Medicare Tax on Investment Income of 3.8%
  • Medicare Part A Tax increase of 0.9%
  • 40% Excise Tax on "Cadillac" plans
  • Annual $63 fee per subscriber to fund “risk corridors”
  • Medicine Cabinet Tax (OTC medicines no longer qualified as medical expenses for HSA/FSA)
  • Additional Tax on HSA Distributions
  • Contributions to FSAs are Reduced
  • Medical Deduction Threshold tax increase
  • Individual Mandate (the tax for not purchasing insurance if you can afford it)
Using static scoring, the Congressional Budget Office has projected the revenue to be garnered from these sources. But humans aren't static and behavior easily morphs. Another source of complexity and uncertainty.

This combination of mandates and complicated funding sources (not to speak of over 11,000 pages of regulations) has made the program mind-numbingly complex and led to the first of many unintended consequences (the recent cancellation of millions of “non-conforming” policies). People are perplexed, puzzled, and, perhaps, a little bit scared.

To the second point, the stated goals of Obamacare are misdirected in that what we want, what we really really want, is to directly improve the health of the American public. Obamacare assumes that insurance for all will improve general health. And it might.

But if we’re in a mandating mood, then let’s mandate that sugar and fructose and salt and unhealthy fats be removed from our diets. Require that people eat high fiber, low glycemic-index diets under threat of penalty. Demand that everyone walk 10,000 steps per day (age adjusted) or pay a sloth tax.

According to Harvard Health, the medical costs of poor diet and obesity run nearly $200 billion per year to treat diabetes, cancer, heart disease, etc.  That amount, if even partially avoided, would most assuredly “bend the cost curve”.

But we are Americans, free of spirit in our loose fitting clothes. We’d rather purchase mandated “essential” insurance coverage than have our love affair with junk food disrupted. As voters, that’s our prerogative. And who knows - it just might work.

Sunday, January 29, 2012

Corporations that we love to hate

Amadeo Giannini, founder, Bank of America
In 1904, Amadeo Giannini founded the Bank of Italy in San Francisco, California.   At the time, banks catered to the wealthy and couldn’t be bothered with the paltry deposits nor minuscule loans of Italian immigrants.  His bank grew quickly, with deposits totaling $18 million by the end of the first year of operation (2010 dollars).  Giannini’s bank, due to good fortune and arduous effort, survived the San Francisco earthquake of 1906.  He was able to reopen immediately after the quake, whereas other banks were closed for weeks.  His was the only source of loans to individuals and businesses trying to rebuild, and the bank flourished.

Over 100 years later, the Bank of America, directly descended from Giannini’s immigrant-friendly depository, has become the corporation that we love to hate.  In November, Occupy San Francisco protestors stormed a Bank of America branch, pounded on desks, defaced walls, and shouted their message, “make banks pay!”  The Federal Housing Finance Agency sued BoA in September, and the Massachusetts Attorney General joined the fray in December.

The Bank of America is, apparently, greedy, corrupt, evil, and yields no benefit to society.  Let’s put them out of business!

Or, perhaps, sit back first and ponder a few facts.

In 2010 (last year available), BoA employed nearly 300,000 workers to whom they paid over $35 billion in wages, health insurance, Social Security, and Medicare taxes. Those employees all paid federal and state income taxes amounting to billions of dollars on those earnings.  And BoA pays billions more in local property taxes for its thousands of properties across the nation.

The greedy shareholders of the bank are looking only for profit; the more, the better.  Who are these gluttonous capitalists?  One example is the teachers, fireman, police, and state workers of California, where CALPERS owns nearly half a billion dollars in BoA stock and fervently hopes that the investment grows.  Otherwise, pension benefits, and retirements, will be endangered.

All of this is not intended to make you want to remain with BoA if you are an unhappy customer.  But the answer is not new government regulations and politically inspired litigation.  The answer is to exercise some personal initiative. 

If you are unhappy with your bank’s fees, try one of these:
  •       Consolidate and build your accounts in order to attain the amount needed for free checking.
  •       Pay off your credit card balance in full each month.
  •       Don't overdraw your account or make a late payment.
  •       Find a local bank or credit union and move your accounts.  They will welcome you.
  •       Start your own bank.

While that last one may seem whimsical, it is not.  All you need is to sign up shareholders to kick in $4-$10 million (usually 500-1,000 like-minded investors).  Then, incorporate and make a charter application to your state or the federal government.  (Yes, you must become a nasty, corporate capitalist, by law, in order to form a bank).

Once your charter is approved (typically 180 days or more), you are in business and can begin hiring employees, accepting deposits, and making loans.  Remember that the goal of the business is to make a profit and repay the investors.  In addition, as you build your deposits, you may make more loans to worthy individuals and businesses.  If any of those loans are not repaid, you must still ensure that your depositors’ funds are safe and can be refunded on demand, and also retain the faith of your investors.

So while you may sympathize with the Occupy crew, perhaps a whiff of reality will help you see a broader picture.  Corporations in general, and banks in particular, are simply associations of  like-minded people who strive to provide services and earn a profit in return.  In the process of doing so, they create a multitude of jobs and pay a staggering burden of wages and taxes to various jurisdictions.  That can’t be all bad.



Monday, May 18, 2009

The Grapes of Wrath -- do-over

An article in the weekend Wall Street Journal (“’Youth Magnet’ Cities Hit Midlife Crisis”, 5/16/09) describes the migration patterns of some of our most prized citizens. College educated, single people between 25 and 39 years old are the basis for economic rejuvenation, high pay (and high tax revenue) jobs, and cultural vibrancy that make them greatly sought after. A study of these patterns reveals the top 20 cities which are the beneficiaries of this net, in-migration. Because these productive citizens are motivated both by climate and the “cool” factor, it is not surprising that Phoenix and Seattle top the list.

Question: what do Boston, Providence, Hartford, Portland ME, Burlington VT, and Concord NH have in common? Answer: they are not on the list. As a matter of fact, neither is any other city in New England, nor the top three megaplexes: New York, Chicago or Los Angles. No, these places are all donors of the young, cool, educated, productive workforce; not recipients.

How does one explain this phenomenon? There are many factors, but here’s something to consider – freedom.

Earlier this year, the Mercatus Center at George Mason University published an analysis, “Freedom in the 50 States: An Index of Personal and Economic Freedom.” This study ranks the 50 states in terms of social, personal, and economic freedom. The aberrant New England “live free or die” state of New Hampshire ranked first, with the greatest overall freedom, whereas New York state ranked dead last by a country mile. The other New England states (MA, RI, CT, VT, ME) averaged a stultifying 42nd. The megaplex states (NY, CA, IL) averaged 46th overall. The land of the free isn’t very much so in great swathes of the country.

How did the top-20 destination cities mentioned above fare? Two of them are in California (Sacramento and Riverside), a bow to climate and “cool” in spite of California’s 47th place freedom ranking. The remaining 18 destination cities are in states whose average ranking is 15th – much better than average. And the top destination state (Texas, with 4 of the top 20 cities) ranks 5th. Hmmm – there may be something to this theory.

Recent news item – Rhode Island, with a total population just over 1,000,000 people, has about 400,000 people employed. Let’s put this into perspective. Imagine a prehistoric tribe of 10 persons including children and the elderly. The survival of the clan rests entirely on 4 individuals. For every rabbit snared, the 4 workers must feed themselves and 6 additional mouths. They must, at times, feel a bit put-upon and wonder if the others might at least gather some berries. In fact, they might just be tempted to pull up stakes and move to Texas.